Showing posts with label Steve Huff. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Steve Huff. Show all posts


Springfield, Illinois resident Klutzo the Clown was arrested October 9, 2007 and charged with possession of child pornography. Authorities allege that Klutzo, who is actually named A. (for Amon) Paul Carlock, Jr., took photos of nude little boys at an orphanage in the Philippines.

It's tempting to make some sort of joke relating to Krusty the Clown and that other Springfield, but there's really nothing funny about this story, if you just stop and think about it.

On paper, Paul Carlock Jr. looked like a true pillar of the community, the kind of guy you might actually want to be around your kid: he'd worked over 2 decades in law enforcement, as a Juvenile Counselor for the Illinois Department of Corrections; he'd been a patrolman and then a Youth Division detective for the Springfield PD; he was an ordained minister.

Carlock frequently performed as a clown with his wife -- he was Klutzo, she was "Smilee." No hint of anything inappropriate could be gleaned from the couples' website (his wife is not charged with anything and may have even filed for divorce):

clowncapers.esmartkid.com/index.html [link goes to archived version, original site down].

If the charges against A. Paul Carlock Jr. are true, he was a predator. Hindsight makes some messages that Carlock left on the Web look more suspicious than they probably seemed when he made them...


According to the complaint filed against Carlock by the feds, he was stopped at the San Francisco International Airport on June 12, 2007 in part because he was coming from the Philippines, and that country is "considered high risk for child sex tourism and child pornography."

Carlock said he'd been there to visit an orphanage named "House of Joy."

He also said he'd been there before.

This appears to be the home page for the "House of Joy."

A guestbook could be found here. A third of the way down the page was this message, left sometime prior to 2006 -- emphasis has been added:
I hope everyone is fine there. From your site it seems that all is well.

I hope to come again sometime in 2006. Would love to clown at the schools while there.

If it is possible, I would like to stay busy by helping your house parents. Maybe they could take a few days off with pay while I fill in for them free of charge.

God Bless
Paul Carlock "Klutzo"
Springfield, Illinois USA
The next mention of Klutzo associated with the "House of Joy" was found halfway down this web page:
House of Joy has a visitor from Illinois, USA. He is Paul Carlock, a policeman and a professional clown. He will stay for 3 weeks.
His daily schedule was very busy because he go to one school to another to share his talent to the children.
Mr.Paul Carlock, thank you for entertaining the children of House of Joy and the Children of San Isidro.
The photos accompanying the blurb about Klutzo were all uploaded in February, 2004.

Paul "Klutzo" Carlock Jr. had photos with him when the authorities stopped him in June, too. They were, according to the complaint, "numerous images of nude young males," who were between 5 and 10 years of age. The boys were shown "playing, showering, and sitting clothed but with genitals visible." Some children were aware of the camera, others were not.

A. Paul Carlock Jr. from Illinois also had an Amazon profile. He said he was a "filmfanatic," and he'd reviewed 10 movies. The movies are interesting by themselves, but it is more illustrative of where Carlock was coming from to note the "tags" he used for the movies he liked. Again, emphasis has been added:
boy (3), devotion (2), loyalty (2), bonding (1), child (1), coming of age (1), comitment (1), commitment (1), crafty (1), endearment (1), goofy (1), hope (1), kidnapping (1), love (1), miracle (1), mischievous fun (1), moving (1), parenting (1), relationship (1), silly (1), socialization (1), trickster (1)
It isn't the sort of evidence that would make it into a court case against Carlock, but again, in hindsight, it is hard to read the list of tags above and not nod and think, "it figures." To read Paul Carlock's reviews of various DVDs, most of them with children prominently displayed on the covers, click here.

Carlock tried to explain his way out of the situation in San Francisco. He said of the nude children, "That's how they live."

But by mid-September, the jig was up for Klutzo. Authorities in the Philippines interviewed three children, a 9-year-old and two 10-year-olds. From the October 9th complaint against Carlock:
All three minors made sworn statements in which they stated that they woke up to Paul Carlock fondling and caressing their penis and that he walked out of the room when they awoke.
Back in the States, Carlock's wife told investigators that Klutzo had been in the Big Brothers program for about 2 months. A 6-year-old boy was assigned to Carlock.

The boy was interviewed. He had not been molested, but one of the two DVDs he'd been given by Carlock held photos of nude filipino boys and girls.

Investigators had seized computers and other media from Carlock by the end of September. The complaint stated that they found more than 20 movies on various items taken from Carlock's home -- all of it child pornography.

The feds will have the last laugh on Klutzo the Clown.

Consider, though -- Carlock was born in 1949, and by his own account, he's been "involved in pastoral ministry, Christian education, Christian camping and evangelism since 1967."

Reading about how Paul Carlock was into "Christian camping" (whatever that is) 40 years ago was enough to induce some queasiness. After all, how long could this "orphan toucher's" (thanks, BelchSpeak) trail of victims be? Surely he didn't start "touching" in his 50s?

If Carlock is guilty of molestation, child-sex tourism, and the child porn charges against him, he has been a demonstrable hypocrite for more than 20 years. The Peoria Journal Star reported the following on October 10:
In December 1986, Carlock wrote a letter to the State Journal-Register complaining about a cartoon. In it, he said he was a conservative Christian and not ashamed of the fact.

"I am not in favor of censorship, but do feel that far too much 'smut' has been poured into the minds of Americans by all forms of media," he wrote.

"I have spent the past 16 years in law enforcement and related professions. I have spoken with victims and offenders and have read many case histories in which pornographic materials played an overwhelming role in the events that have left lives shattered and homes broken."

Later in the letter, he wrote: "Why is it so unreasonable to assume the government has the right to protect the public from the harmful effects of pornography (especially in light of the vast amounts of evidence to support this claim)?"
There are plenty of adults who have an appropriate interest in children. Coaches who just want to teach kids to love a game, to enjoy sports. Teachers who feel called to mold young minds: Ministers, rabbis or [even] priests who feel led to teach children spiritually.

When people want to bemoan a culture of fear, where a normal adult male might walk away from an unfamiliar child crying and alone in a shopping mall for fear of being viewed as a predator if he speaks to the kid, they are forgetting the reason that fear has grown -- stories about guys who play the clown.

Tubby, funny, surely endearing, and just waiting for the time when the orphans finally fall asleep.

Magnanimous in their casual offers to help beleaguered single parents, foster parents, house parents, always "free of charge."

UPDATE, 10/12/2007

The Springfield (Il.) State Journal-Register has a new article about Carlock up today. The lede is a statement that should come as no surprise:
One thing appears certain. Wherever A. Paul Carlock Jr. was, children were not far away.
Go figure.

Other Source: "Christian Clown Busted For Kiddie Porn," WaPo's OFF/beat Weblog.

This post also published at The True Crime Weblog.

Sphere: Related Content
read more “Klutzo the Clown and his International Travels”

Thirty years ago this summer the City of New York was gripped by fear. The "Son of Sam," was on the loose, and no one knew when he'd kill again.

Sam focused his attention on Queens and the Bronx. His preferred targets were couples in parked cars. Dark-haired women who wore their hair long seemed to be what would attract Sam to a particular car.

The Son of Sam wrote insane letters to the press and the authorities. Sometimes Sam's ramblings bordered on a sick sort of poetry, and this was perhaps one of the things that added an extra layer of terror to his legacy. The killer's letter sent to columnist Jimmy Breslin in May, 1977 was but one example of how this particular killer saw the world, and how he used language to intensify the public fear of him. The letter began,

Hello from the gutters of N.Y.C., which are filled with dog manure, vomit, stale wine, urine, and blood. Hello from the sewers of N.Y.C. which swallow up the delicacies when they are washed away by the sweeper trucks. Hello from the cracks in the sidewalks of N.Y.C. and from the ants that dwell in these cracks and feed on the dried blood of the dead that has seeped into these cracks...

The Son of Sam was arrested on August 10, 1977. That was when the public learned his real name, David Berkowitz. The .44 caliber killer, the monster, was a nebbishy former postal worker. He was tripped up, it turned out, by a parking ticket.

For his crimes David Berkowitz received a sentence of 25 years to life in prison.

Since his incarceration Berkowitz has claimed to be a born-again Christian. At a website built for him, Berkowitz peddles a book based on his prison diaries. The book is titled Son of Hope.

*****

Seven years before the Son of Sam began to kill couples making out in parked cars, before he began to send bizarre, disturbing letters to the press, a similar killer was at work on the West Coast. This killer targeted young couples parked in isolated spots at night. One set of victims was attacked outdoors, during the daylight, but they still fit this killer's victim profile.

This killer's letters were published in the papers. Many of his letters contained meticulously-rendered coded messages. Only one of the codes was ever conclusively solved.

The Zodiac Killer killed 5 and injured 2. Many believe they know who The Zodiac was, but no one has ever been arrested for his crimes.

Forty-seven years before the Son of Sam, thirty-nine years before Zodiac, there was 3X. He didn't take as many victims as his spiritual offspring. Technically, he may not have been a serial killer. The 3X killer caused a brief flurry of news coverage in papers nationwide before everyone went back to worrying about where to find a job, or the next square meal.

He stalked amorous couples in cars, couples who thought they'd found respite from prying eyes. The 3X killer then wrote letters about what he'd done, and what he might do next. In these letters there were rambling and disjointed passages similar to some found in the letters sent by Zodiac and the Son of Sam. Like the Zodiac Killer, 3X was fond of coded messages.

Like the Zodiac, the 3X Killer got away with murder.

Night spawned the stranger. The man from nowhere wore a black suit and a black fedora. He carried a silver gun.

Lovers Joseph Mozynski and Catherine May were wary, frightened. Joseph, a grocer, was married to another woman, with whom he had two children. Catherine was only 19. They'd chosen their isolated parking spot with care. Was the strange man outside Joseph's car a police detective? A private detective? A robber?

The stranger ordered Mozynski to move from the back seat into the front of the vehicle. Then he shot Joseph Mozynski at point-blank range. A bullet split Mozynski's skull, splintering bone, shredding brain matter. Death was instantaneous.

The stranger then turned his attention to Catherine May. He ordered the terrified girl from the vehicle.

Early news reports detailing the murder of Joseph Mozynski depicted the killer as a gentleman -- once the killing was done. New York papers told of the murderer rifling Catherine's purse. He found some letters she was carrying and burned them. The gunman then walked the traumatized young woman to a trolley. Before she boarded a car to go home, the man handed Catherine a note. Stamped in red ink on the paper in Catherine's hand was the following cryptic message:

Joseph Mozynski
3X3-X-097

It took two weeks for the press to report a crucial detail omitted from the first reports about the death of Joseph Mozynski. Before the "courtly" killer ensured Catherine May's safe passage home, his strange message in her possession, he raped her.

The police decided to hold Ms. May on a $50,000 bond until they were satisfied that she had nothing to do with her lover's demise. A 23-year-old friend of May's named Joseph Moisette traveled to New York from Chicago at police request. It took more than a week, but investigators finally concluded that neither Moisette nor Catherine May were responsible for Joseph Mozynski's murder.

Two days after Mozynski was murdered, a bizarre letter was sent to a New York newspaper. In part, it read:

kindly print this letter in your paper for Mozynski's friends: "CC-NY ADCM-Y16a-DQR-PA...241 PM6 Queens." By doing this you may save their lives. We do not want any more shooting unless we have to...

The next day, June 14, another letter came. It said that the "dirty rat" Mozynski was supposed to have "certain documents." The writer then said that "unfortunately, they were not in his possession at the time."

The letter writer described the gun and ammo used to kill Mozynski, and at the end of the letter he issued a warning. Unless the killer received some important documents, "14 more of Mozynski's friends will join him."

It was June 11, 1930, and the beginning of a truly bizarre mystery.

*****

The man who stepped out of the darkness 5 days later was following a script known only to him. Certain elements were fixed in place -- the night, a parked car, the lovers inside the car.

The stranger standing outside Noel Sowley's auto wanted to see Sowley's license. Sowley, 26, was parked in an out of the way spot with his girlfriend, Elizabeth Ring.

After examining the license, the man turned away from Sowley's car. He raised a flashlight and flicked it off and on, as if broadcasting some kind of code. Turning back to Sowley, he said, "You're the one we want, all right. You're going to get what Joe got."

Then the stranger shot the radio salesman from Brooklyn. Two bullets to the brain, and Noel Sowley was dead.

The killer leaned over and whispered, "Now you've got the same dose as the other fellow." He dug through Sowley's pockets, finally pulling out a piece of paper. He said, "I have it!"

Noel Sowley's murderer concluded his business with Sowley's corpse by dropping a newspaper clipping in Sowley's lap. In the margin of the clipping were scribbled these words: "Here's how." The article was about the murder of Joseph Mozynski.

Elizabeth Ring might have been raped like Catherine May, but she reportedly avoided the outrage by showing the killer some kind of "religious medal." The man walked Ring to a bus stop to catch a ride home.

*****

Though police had yet to find Noel Sowley's remains the following day, another mysterious letter had already arrived at the William Randolph Hearst-owned New York Journal. The tabloid Journal was already infamous for the way its publisher had literally helped to foment the Spanish-American War with dramatic accounts of Spanish "atrocities" in Cuba.

The letter described Noel Sowley's murder from the killer's point of view. It didn't stop there. The killer had also sent along two cartridge casings. Sowley was referred to as "V-5 Sowley," and it was apparent that the killer believed Sowley to be "one more of Mozynski's friends."

There was another warning in this letter. The killer stated that 13 men and a woman would be killed "if they do not make peace with us and stop bleeding us to death."

For the moment, mobsters and most other workaday malefactors were forgotten. A massive police force was deployed to find the madman. Suspects, new witnesses were sought. In Queens alone 700 cops hit the streets. That night, patrolmen and plainclothesmen were stationed in places where lovers typically liked to park. A number of patrolmen, likely to their chagrin, were dressed as women.

As many as 18 arrests were made in New York, New Jersey, and Philadelphia. Neither of the surviving victims recognized any of the arrestees.

Other than finding Noel Sowley's body keeled over in his car sometime that Tuesday, police had no luck.

*****

A few days after the Sowley murder, the man some reporters had dubbed the "massacre maniac" ("petterkiller" was another epithet) issued an apology in the form of a new letter to the Journal. He said he had marked another man for death, the murder to take place at 9 on the night of the 18th in College Point, Long Island.

That man, said 3X, had saved himself. The killer wrote:

Dear Sir: I beg to thank you for publishing the code message sent you. W. R. XVG of C. P. (College Point) has returned the Philadelphia XV 340 to me tonight -- also 37,000 dollars of blackmail money, thanks to God, if I may use his name.

According to 3X, "W. R." had also saved 5 other people, one of them a tall blond woman.

But it wasn't time for anyone in Queens or the surrounding boroughs to relax. 3X said he still had 7 victims to go. The killer provided a code for the identities of the victims he still planned to kill: X14, X21, Y2, O6, X7, S1, and V4.

All was not yet lost for these people, though. Three-X would let them live, he said, if they followed directions in yet another encoded message: N. J.--C. C. K.--2-33-A. V.-3X-R. G.-4 MLT-RP 49-6.

Handwriting experts and "war code" experts in Washington and Chicago were on the case. The handwriting analysts could, if nothing else, weed out fakes from the real thing, and the code experts might be able to tell if there was a real pattern to 3X's ciphers or if he was simply a lunatic spouting gibberish.

On or about June 19, another missive apparently authored by 3X was sent to the Journal. It was peculiar in part because it was reportedly written in ink on purple paper. In it he called himself "X -- the man behind the gun." The letter read:

Find the Woman

Where is X8 2-9? He is already dead. He is on the Boston Road. His name is Harold Bridenbach. Find the woman, old man, and you've got me.

One of the many remaining puzzles in the case of the 3X killer is this letter -- was it from the killer at all? There was an importer of precious stones named Harold Breidenbach living in the killer's general target area at the time. (The 1930 Federal Census had just been taken in April of that year.) A close look at several genealogical records seemed to indicate that this Harold Breidenbach lived to a ripe old age, passing away in California in the 1970s. As it was, the police never turned up a definitive third victim of 3X. They never even knew if they were searching on the right Boston Road -- the Boston Post Road inside Manhattan city limits, or the Boston Road further out from the metropolis.

There was a mysterious explosion in College Point on the very night police were searching there for the 3X victim the killer later said he'd decided to spare. The blast was heard by some of the cops on stakeouts at typical trysting spots (including the hapless guys in drag). Nervous locals were naturally thrown into a panic. But 3X was never actually linked to the explosion. Still, true crime writers and reporters in later years would assist in the ballooning of the 3X legend, turning him into not just a killer, but a "mad bomber."

The killer did threaten to expand his operations to Pennsylvania. His victim of choice there was none other than Joseph Mozynski's brother John, who lived in Port Richmond, PA. Sometime between June 19 and June 21, 3X mailed threats to John Mozynski. Understandably, John turned his home into a fortress for a time.

The surviving Mozynski brother was safe, though. By June 21, the 3X killer had sent what he said would be his final letter. In this rambling and disjointed message 3X outlined a scenario to explain his actions. It was straight out of a spy novel.

The killer said he was an agent of the "Russian Red Diamond Society." A plane had been secretly chartered to take him back to Europe. He wrote, "3-X is no more. My mission is ended."

Most of the letters from 3X had been signed with this strange set of symbols: Λ V 3X. Now that he was "leaving," 3X helpfully explained what the sign-off meant:

The first sign means A, the supreme tribunal of the order. The second V, its secret agent. The two combined form the Red Diamond of Russia, a secret order all over the world...

The writer segued into what appeared to be his justification for killing Joseph Mozynski and Noel Sowley:

Anyone breaking [the Red Diamond of Russia's] rules is marked for death. These men were dismissed from the order for treason. They were all our friends but came in contact with a gang of blackmailers and a drug ring and turned against us...

He continued in this vein, his story self-contradictory, confusing. He concluded with:

Quiet your people and tell them 3 X is no more. If any more letters come they are fakes. I am leaving today on my way back to Russia. (...) There is no one else to begin trouble. It is settled.

H. P. 12. W. A.

In another message 3X had referred to himself as a former German Army officer, and he'd given slightly different reasons for what he was doing -- none of it written with the specificity of his "final" letter.

The lunatic who called himself 3X vanished, as if the night that spawned him had called him home again.

*****

There were a handful of 3X suspects over the years. One was a former church worker from Long Island who'd had delusions similar to the phantom killer's -- of being an agent, of needing to recover something important like a document. Another suspect was an escapee from a mental hospital named Joseph Ustica. Ustica had homicidal tendencies, and the Italian-born inmate of Kings Park State Hospital had escaped around the time the 3X killings began. Many of Ustica's delusions were about being on some sort of mission involving special documents.

Ultimately, Ustica's physical description did not match the one given by either Catherine May or Elizabeth Ring.

A tie between the couples attacked by 3X that was not readily apparent in most of the news coverage at the time was adultery.

Though the killer allegedly raped Catherine May and wanted to rape Elizabeth Ring, a few newspapers referred to him as a "moral maniac." The assumption prior to May's rape being revealed was that 3X had taken offense at the couples doing dirty deeds in their cars, and that this had fueled his murderous rage.

That 3X eliminated the male and treated the females alternately as sexual objects then with something resembling courtesy seemed to fly in the face of any true "moral" sensibility contributing to his actions. Morality as understood by a clinically insane killer, perhaps, but not morality as it would have been perceived at the time.

It was known shortly after Mozynski's murder that he was cheating on his wife with Catherine May. However, the adultery embodied in Noel Sowley's relationship with Elizabeth Ring was not so obvious. No mention of it could be found in any of the reports published by wire services at the time. To any casual reader of a 3X story published at the time it seemed as though one couple was indeed an older man catting around with a hot young thing, but the other was just two fairly young people doing what young folks often do. In the 1930 Census Noel Sowley was not listed as a married man -- he had two boarders, Elton Hall and Fred Jiles, both 21.

A web search revealed that Elizabeth Ring was a different story.

At Bklyn-genealogy-info.com, someone has published old news briefs from the Brooklyn Daily Standard Union. An interesting article about Elizabeth Ring was posted there.

The following was originally published in the Daily Standard Union on March 20, 1931:

WITNESS IN 3X MURDER DIVORCED.

The marital bonds that joined Elizabeth RING LAUSTEEN and Vincent J. LAUSTEEN, 22 year old advertising solicitor, have been severed by Justice Mitchell MAY in the Special Term of the Queens Supreme Court, with the signing of a final decree of divorce.

LAUSTEEN, on Dec. 2, brought the action before Justice Burt Jay HUMPHREY, claiming that his young wife was in a wooded section in Creedmore with Noel SOWLEY on June 16, the night SOWLEY was murdered by the elusive 3-X.

LAUSTEEN testified that while her actions with SOWLEY were not known by him, he was sure that the pretty brunette was not in a parked car with SOWLEY talking about the weather. Justice HUMPHREY signed the interlocutory decree of divorce when Mrs. LAUSTEEN didn't appear in court to defend the case. Throughout the investigation of the murder, Mrs. LAUSTEEN was referred to as Betty RING, daughter of a policeman. Young LAUSTEEN gave his address as 93-10 206th street, Queens Village.

Vincent's last name may have been spelled "Laustein." When census takers came to the Queens home of Lauritz and Gisela Laustein two months before 3X first struck, 21-year-old Vincent, a "producer of advertising," was living there. No Elizabeth Ring was listed as a member of the Laustein household.

Yet when the census came to Jamaica Township (Queens County) and the home of city policeman David Ring, a 20-year-old Elizabeth was listed as living at home with her parents. Beside Elizabeth's name the census taker had added "Lawson."

It may be safe to conclude that the young couple was already having trouble when Elizabeth's fateful tryst with Noel Sowley turned into a living nightmare.

Still, it is hard to not wonder just how angry young Vincent might have been with his wife. And it is interesting that Elizabeth's father was a cop, and somehow her being married was kept out of most news reports about the 3X crimes. That may be no coincidence.

Further theorizing about the truth behind the 3X murders can be perilous, though. Far too little is known to develop theories that make much sense. The mind tends to wander in directions that seem as strange as those taken by 3X himself in his weird letters to the press.

But an underlying commonality between the couples attacked, where at least one partner in each pairing was cheating on someone else -- that's hard to ignore. It is also hard to ignore the fact that this went virtually unreported at the time.

Could it be that 3X didn't exist? It would have been interesting to know if there was some link between the couples themselves -- Catherine May knowing Elizabeth Ring, or Joseph Mozynski, perhaps. Even if it was just a casual, "hello, how are you" sort of thing.

If there had been some sort of prior acquaintance, could the women have cooked something up between them to escape cleanly from unseemly relationships? It seems far-fetched, but then again, so did 3X's actions and his letters.

If 3X did not truly exist, he could have also been created in another way.

It is worth noting that it was the New York Journal doing so much in-depth reporting of the 3X story. William Hearst had virtually invented "yellow journalism" with that paper. Scandals, gossip, lurid and sensational crime stories were the Journal's stock and trade. A long-standing theory about several letters from Jack the Ripper is that they were written by London newsmen trying to scare up more opportunities to sell papers. The theory has some solid grounding. Many Ripperologists do believe the real killer sent at least one letter (the one that begins, "Dear Boss..."), but they also tend to think most other Ripper notes were hoaxes.

What if the Journal took a page from that playbook? On one hand you could say that it made sense for a psycho killer to make it a point to send all his correspondence to the most high-profile scandalsheet in town, on the other hand, it would have also made sense for a paper run by the poster boy for yellow journalism to completely manufacture the most exotic element of this tale of murder.

Nearly 80 years after the fact, it is a virtual certainty that we will never know exactly what happened in June, 1930. 3X could have been burying tidbits of truth in his letters, if he was the real killer. His final message about "going to Europe" could have been euphemistic -- he might have committed suicide. In the letters reprinted by news services at the time there wasn't much of the cold-hearted but still legally sane psychopath -- that the letter writer was either making up an elaborate fiction or was truly delusional seemed more likely.

3X could have simply moved to another city, and decided that it didn't serve his best interests to taunt the police as he'd done before. Any subsequent murders would not have been easily traced to him -- not in 1930, with the Great Depression really starting to kick it into high gear.

3X could have also finally been brought under control by someone who recognized his insanity. A long-standing theory about the Cleveland Torso Killer (also called the Butcher of Kingsbury Run) is that he was the clinically insane scion of a very prominent Cleveland family, and he ended his days in an asylum. Could 3X's murderous spree have been stopped by similar circumstances?

One thing will always be true about 3X. It is another trait common to him and the Zodiac Killer. Because he was never caught, because his real name was never known, it doesn't matter if he was in whole or in part a fictional creation.

Whether he was flesh or dark, awful fantasy, the 3X Killer remains a true phantom to this very day.

Sources not otherwise linked in this post:

(This blog entry originally published at CrimeBlog.US.)

Sphere: Related Content
read more “Berkowitz, Zodiac, and Λ V 3X”

Three months to the day after she was murdered, I received an e-mail from Tori Vienneau.

To be precise, the e-mail was from a website that purported to help people stay in contact with old friends from school, the military, even former places of employment. The words in my Gmail inbox raised the hair on the back of my neck: "Steve, You have mail from Tori Vienneau!"

In my own account with the reunion website I was to find what appeared to be a message from a dead woman.


****
The e-mail I received on October 26, 2006 was actually from Tori Vienneau's mother, Dayna Herroz. Dayna had accessed one of Tori's online accounts after she'd found blog posts by me as well as message board discussions by others about her daughter's and grandson's murders. Dayna wanted to talk about them.

Who the hell was I? Who the hell were all these people on my blog and on message boards? Why did we think we had the right to talk about what happened to Tori, and Tori's son, Dean Springstube? The single most painful event in the life of any parent, and Dayna Herroz had discovered an active web discussion about it by a bunch of people who didn't know her or her family from Adam, much less Eve.

I told Dayna -- We weren't talking about the murders because we were sick. We were discussing them because they sickened us. How could a mother and her infant son be so brutally and callously killed in their own home, and there not be some sort of arrest immediately? What kind of monster would do that to other people, to a bright, sweet young woman and a defenseless infant?


****

On the night of July 26, 2006, someone brutally attacked Tori Vienneau inside her own apartment, in San Diego, California. Tori was beaten and strangled.

Tori was dressed up to go out that night. She was supposed to have a talk with her son's father. The topic: child support.

Though Dean had the last name of Tori's most steady man, Neal Springstube, the meeting that night wasn't with Neal. It was with Dean's biological father, Dennis Potts. Potts and Tori had known each other for years, Dennis had been kind of a "fall-back guy" for her. An ill-advised "fall-back" moment in 2005 had brought about Dean's conception.

Dennis tried to deny his paternity. He may have even tried to fake the results of a DNA test he'd agreed to take. Recently, though, it seemed like he was stepping up, taking responsibility. He'd already visited the apartment to get acquainted with Dean on other occasions.

Dennis Potts's biological son also died from asphyxiation that night.

Little Dean was found hanging from a noose in his crib.


****

After we began to communicate, first over e-mail and then also by phone, Dayna Herroz realized that I was telling her the truth: Most of those weird people she'd encountered talking about this horrific double murder were still discussing it because we couldn't believe that the monster who committed the crime was still out there somewhere, roaming free.

Using an e-mail moniker containing the appropriate word "Tigress," Dayna embraced us, and the embrace was returned in kind.

Via San Diego TV station KFMB and my group-authored weblog, CrimeBlog.US, Dennis Potts was outed as a suspect in the murders of Tori and Dean. For a time, Dennis understandably took himself out of public circulation, removing profiles from MySpace, taking down websites he'd erected for various business ventures. After San Diego police reacted with some concern about Dennis being named, even Dayna backed away -- a little. We all waited for something new to shake loose. Dennis Potts stepped out into view again, even began a website for a new business.

By May 26, 2006, exactly ten months after Tori's and Dean's murders, Dayna Herroz had had enough. She went public. To multiple media outlets, Dayna sent out a flyer containing a photo of Tori and Dean and a compelling message. It read, in part:

I am Tori's mother and Dean's grandmother. She was my only child, the light of my life, and Dean was an angel on earth. Everyone that knew them knew instantly the animal responsible for this horrific double homicide in San Diego. That said we also thought we would have an arrest within days. It will be 10 months since the murders Saturday, May 26. We have had little media attention locally or nationally in regards to this case. So we are pleading with you to please help us bring attention to the murders of two very innocent people. When Laci Peterson was murdered it was front-page news and on every media outlet across this country, and in my opinion it was crucial in the arrest of Scott Peterson. There is strength in numbers, and when all of those people joined together in the fight for justice for Laci & Connor there was no way to hide. When I say that I mean for Scott Peterson and the legal system in charge of the investigation and those involved when it went to trial. I was naïve enough at that time to believe that no one would ever kill the mother of their child, and their own baby ever again. I was wrong. The only difference is in this case (...) it was my daughter was murdered, and this time the child was alive and well for 10 months before being hung like an animal from his crib (...) I don't understand is why no one will touch this story. So I am pleading with you, please help us find justice for Tori and Dean...
Dayna Herroz sent her press release to every blogger, MySpacer, message board poster she'd ever come in contact with, as well as any media contact she could find.

Something had to happen, surely.


****

On June 5, 2007, Dayna wrote the following in an e-mail to me:

[Since] Memorial Day we have had an overwhelming response from people on the Internet joining in the fight for justice, and writing to the various media outlets and law enforcement agencies. Locally we have had volunteers handing out hundreds of flyers all over town, some going door to door or in the parking lots of major stores and asking anyone they can find to please help us bring attention to Tori and Dean.

(...)

I have not heard back(,) from one person that has been helping us(,) of anyone who ever heard of Tori and Dean's case!!!

Many very kind people have sent me e-mails telling me some of the nicest things I've ever heard, and the support that is out there for us is unbelievable, and we would never have known had I not gone public, because no one tells you that...
Good news, on the whole. Will something more come from Dayna's actions? It's hard to tell. Only the investigators truly know the kind of evidence they have, and whether or not that evidence will ever be enough to make an arrest.

Many times, true crime narratives are written after a case has been adjudicated. There are exceptions, such as stories about famous unsolved murders, but most writers and publishers (I'm told), like for the story to have some sort of resolution.

Writing about the murders of Tori Vienneau and Dean Springstube has been, at times, frustrating. The story unfolds, but it only goes so far.

And sometimes writing about Tori and Dean has felt more like activism than writing. Being the lone blogger who named a suspect for the first time was a nerve-wracking experience. I have had more than one moment when I wanted to be a little more removed from events, more the observer, less the actor.

When I felt that way, I would go back to my first impressions as I read a short news article at the end of July, 2006. About the murdered single mother and her baby, found hanging in his crib. I would resurrect the cold chill I felt at perceiving the outlines of something monstrous in the crisp, detached, AP-style narrative.

I have considered, should an arrest ever be made in relation to Tori's and Dean's murders, writing a book about the case. I sometimes stop that train of thought, though, and ask myself if I'm perhaps too close.

At the moment, I don't know.

I do know that my connection to the story, to the people who so unwillingly became part of the story, was sealed the moment I opened my e-mail one day late in October, and saw that I had a new message from the dead.

Sphere: Related Content
read more “Messages from the Dead: Tori and Dean”

In Cold Blog is a true crime blog founded by best selling author Corey Mitchell, and is written by award winning journalists, authors, criminal justice professionals and others.

Click to...

Join Our Fan Page on Facebook!

Site Archive

Share Us With Friends!

Subscribe


Subscribe to Our Feed

Follow us on Twitter

Get New ICB Posts by Email:

Delivered by FeedBurner


Today's Featured News & Posts

Our Recent Articles

Blogumulus by Roy Tanck and Amanda FazaniDistributed by CahayaBiru.com
.
.